Evaluation Of A Good Argument - 1394 Words

7.3 – Neutralization of the fallacy: In paragraph 4 the author has violated the sufficiency criterion of a good argument. The author has violates the sufficiency criteria by committing the fallacy of false analogy. In paragraph 4 the author states, â€Å"In the mid 1940s – before publicly funded healthcare – my grand parents sold their car to pay the hospital bill related to my father’s birth, so â€Å"purchasing† the birth of a child is nothing new.† This is a wrong analogy. Just because you pay for hospital bill and cloning, does not make them the same. In one situation, two persons life is preserved, and in the other a person’s life is changed. The author could have avoided this fallacy by not comparing these two totally different situations at all or giving an analogy that has the same situation as human cloning. 7.4 – Positive Critique: In the fifth paragraph the author argues that the paternal and maternal linages are not the most important thing as what we identify ourselves with us humans, which is quite convincing. As his first premise he states, â€Å"Most people I know do identify with both their maternal and paternal lineages.† As his second premise he states, â€Å"Dual heritage may be normal, but it is seems central to our conception of ourselves as humans.† And as third premise he sates, â€Å"And identical twins seems none worse for the knowledge that they are not genetically unique individuals.† Even though that was said that this argument is convincing, it is not withoutShow MoreRelatedGood Rhetoric, Argument And Writing Essay1336 Words   |  6 PagesMichael Brown English 2010, Section 36 Saturday, August 29, 2015 Good rhetoric, argument and writing What constitutes good rhetoric and argument? How do these factors affect writing? And, the aforementioned questions considered, what practices should then be regarded as bad, or the negation of good? Before these prompts can be adequately addressed, a brief survey on the nature of values is necessary, so as to enframe this discussion of good and bad practices in operationalized terms, localized for ourRead MoreEditorial Evaluation876 Words   |  4 PagesEditorial Evaluation Gabriel Hess City University of Seattle BC301 - Critical Thinking Cheryl-Ann Laws-Brown November 18, 2011 Editorial Evaluation: Feeling poorer? You have plenty of company. USA Today News Could it be true that more people live in poverty today than at any point in the last 50 years? An editorial from the USA Today website titled Feeling poorer? You have plenty of company. presents that exact argument. The following evaluation of this editorial will look at the strengthsRead MoreThe Civil Service And Performance System1366 Words   |  6 Pagesreforms about performance and merit. In his argument, the discussions of the civil service reforms have been dominated by managerial rhetoric (Thompson, 2006, 501). Additionally, he argues that in the current system, performance and merit are not considered keenly as high performers are compensated the same way as poor performers (Thompson, 2006, 496). To provide a solution to this problem, systems have been proposed to reward performers and to promote good governance in the public sector. ThompsonRead MoreThe Detroit Lions And Chicago Lions1734 Words   |  7 PagesSanders era. The audience of this article is mainly towards the local Detroit Lions fans, but can also be towards people who love the NFL or are big fans of the NFL franchise itself. The author also uses some evaluation arguments to get his purpose across the audience. The evaluation argument is ideal for this article because it’s an article where he is comparing one football team to not only the same team in the past, but also all the other teams in the NFL. For example, the author states, â€Å"LastRead MoreEvaluation Criteria for Text Sources1325 Words   |  5 PagesEvaluation Criteria for Text Sources Title and Author of Source: Enoch, Jessica and Jordynn, Jack. Remembering Sappho: new perspectives on teaching and writing womens rhetorical history. College English 73(5): pp. 518-537. Print. (Copy). Retrieved from: ProQuest Database. [Accessed on 31 May 2012]. First, consult the document entitled Guidelines for Evaluating Sources. Then judge the credibility of the all the sources you located (use one worksheet for each source) according to each ofRead MoreRefining Solution Paper719 Words   |  3 Pagesyour situation or budget, but there are some general guidelines to keep in mind. In this paper, the individual will discuss the original issues, initial solution, and the critical examination of the best solution. Also do an evaluation of the argument and revise the argument to come up with a better solution to the problem (University of Phoenix, 2013). As a final point I will refine the solution with an implementation plan and the come up with a final solution to the problem. First, the individualRead MoreArguments Of Proponents And Opponents Of The Safe And Accurate Food Labeling Act1744 Words   |  7 PagesAfter presenting the arguments of proponents and opponents of the Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act. This paper will now analyze each issue to determine the strengths and weakness of each side’s argument. One argument that proponents make about genetically modified food is that they are no different than natural foods. An argument that opponents make is that genetically modified organisms have not been tested enough because they are fairly new and some scientist truly don’t have an understandingRead MoreHow My Writing Has Improved Greatly Improved After Taking English 103928 Words   |  4 Pagessemester, my confidence in writing has improved greatly. In high school, I didn’t really know how to write effectively. I wasn’t really sure what was considered to be â€Å"good writing† until I took AP* English. However , even while I was taking this â€Å"Advanced Placement† class, I was still trying to figure out how to really create â€Å"good writing†. I feel as if this had something to do with the fact that I never really had to work with the rules of grammar intensively. After taking this course, however,Read MoreReflection About Self Reflection1343 Words   |  6 Pagesmuch more there was to learn and how much I could improve my writing. I have learned many valuable skills such as researching credible information, using critical thinking and rhetorical strategy, writing mechanics, analyzing and disproving counter-arguments, addressing specific audiences, and using peer editing in my writing process. With my progress throughout this class, I have developed into an exceptional writer which will benefit me in future school and career situations. My ability to researchRead MoreJapanese Culture636 Words   |  3 PagesJapanese culture is fairly staid, traditional, and, for the most part, static. Although there is bound to be a degree of generalizations in any cultural evaluation, the preceding statement certainly applies to Japanese culture. Some of the principle characteristics of Japanese culture that render it distinct from most Westernized ones (especially the United States) are its definitive homogeneity and conventional family structure. In terms of homogeneity, it is significant to note that the vast